Donor segmentation: Best practices to boost giving & retention

When done right, it can help you build stronger relationships, increase donor retention, and make your fundraising efforts more effective. Instead of sending out one-size-fits-all messages, you can personalize your outreach—so donors feel seen, valued, and more likely to give again.

The best part? You don’t need a huge team or a complicated system to make this work. With the right approach, you can start segmenting donors today and see better results in your fundraising efforts.

What is donor segmentation all about?

Donor segmentation is about organizing your supporters into groups based on what makes them unique. Instead of treating every donor the same, you categorize them by things like donation history, communication preferences, or engagement level. This way, you can send the right message to the right people at the right time.

Think of your donor base as a group of friends. Some like texting, others prefer phone calls, and a few only show up for big events. If you knew how each person liked to communicate, you’d have better conversations, right? The same idea applies to fundraising. By segmenting donors, you can build stronger relationships and increase engagement—without sending random, one-size-fits-all messages.

Segmentation also helps you understand your donors better. You’ll start to notice trends, like which supporters give during specific times of the year, who responds best to emails, or who is likely to become a long-term donor. With this knowledge, you can tailor your outreach, increase donations, and make donors feel more connected to your mission.

It’s not about complicating things—it’s about working smarter. Whether you're a small nonprofit or a large organization, donor segmentation can help you maximize your fundraising efforts with less guesswork.

Why donor segmentation is essential for fundraising and engagement

If you want donors to keep giving, you need to keep them engaged. That’s where donor segmentation makes all the difference. By grouping donors based on their giving habits, interests, and communication preferences, you can make every interaction feel more personal—and when donors feel connected, they’re more likely to stick around.

Imagine you have two donors: One gives $20 every month, and the other made a single $500 donation last year. If you send them the same generic message — “Thank you for your support this year!” — it might not resonate deeply with either of them. But if you personalize your outreach, the difference is clear:

“Your monthly gifts help sustain our work all year long — thank you for your steady, ongoing support.”

“Your generous $500 donation helped us launch a new program last spring — here’s what you made possible.”

Now, both donors feel seen and appreciated in a way that’s relevant to their giving style — and that’s what encourages future giving.

Segmentation also helps improve retention rates. Nonprofits lose a lot of donors simply because they don’t follow up in the right way. If someone gives once and never hears from you again—or only gets generic emails—they might not feel inspired to give again. But if you know who your lapsed donors are, you can send them a special message to bring them back. If you track your major donors, you can give them VIP treatment to keep them engaged long-term.

Beyond fundraising, segmentation strengthens donor relationships. When people see that you “get” them—whether through a phone call, a personalized thank-you, or an event invite that matches their interests—they become more invested in your mission. It’s not just about asking for donations; it’s about creating meaningful connections that last.

Key donor segments and how to create segments

Not all donors are the same, so your outreach shouldn’t be either. By breaking your donor base into meaningful groups, you can send messages that actually resonate. Below are some of the most effective ways to segment your donors and why each one matters.

Demographic-based segmentation

Demographics help you understand who your donors are based on factors like age, location, income level, or profession. A young professional in a big city might engage differently than a retired donor in a small town. Knowing these details helps you tailor your fundraising appeals—like sending a social media-driven campaign to younger donors or a personalized letter to older supporters who prefer direct mail.

Behavior-based segmentation

Looking at donor behavior gives you insight into how they interact with your nonprofit. This includes things like:

• Donation frequency (one-time vs. recurring)
• Events attended (fundraisers, volunteer days, galas)
• Social media engagement (likes, shares, comments)

By tracking these behaviors, you can send targeted messages—like thanking event attendees with an exclusive behind-the-scenes update or nudging past volunteers to donate.

Giving level segmentation

Not every donor gives the same amount, and their expectations differ too. Major donors might expect one-on-one conversations or exclusive updates, while small-dollar donors may appreciate a heartfelt email showing how every gift makes a difference. Adjusting your messaging based on giving levels ensures donors feel valued, no matter their contribution.

Communication preference segmentation

Some donors love emails. Others never open them. Some prefer a quick phone call, while others respond better to social media messages. Instead of blasting the same message across all channels, segmenting by communication preferences lets you reach donors in the way they’re most likely to engage.

Engagement-based segmentation

Not every supporter is a donor—yet. Volunteers, event attendees, and social media followers all engage with your nonprofit in different ways. By tracking engagement levels, you can identify potential donors and create strategies to move them toward giving. For example, if someone frequently shares your nonprofit’s posts, they might be interested in joining a peer-to-peer fundraising campaign.

Donor segmentation best practices for nonprofit organizations

Segmenting your donors is a game-changer, but to make it work, you need a solid strategy. Here are some best practices to ensure your segmentation efforts lead to stronger donor relationships and better fundraising results.

Use data to create effective segments

The best donor segments are based on real data—not guesses. Start by gathering key details like giving history, communication preferences, engagement levels, and demographics. A good donor management system (like a CRM) can help you track this information in one place. The more you understand your donors, the better you can segment them in ways that truly matter.

Develop personalized messaging for each type of donor

A major donor and a first-time donor shouldn’t receive the same message. Personalization goes beyond using someone’s name—it’s about sending content that fits their giving habits and interests. For example:

• Lapsed donors: A warm "We miss you!" email with a reminder of their past impact.
• Recurring donors: A monthly update with exclusive behind-the-scenes stories.
• New donors: A welcome series introducing them to your nonprofit’s mission.

The more relevant the message, the more likely donors are to stay engaged.

Leverage automation and AI for segmentation

You don’t have to manually track every donor’s behavior—automation tools can do the heavy lifting. Many nonprofit platforms offer automation features that help you segment donors and send the right message at the right time. AI tools can even predict which donors are likely to lapse or upgrade their giving, so you can take action before it’s too late.

Continuously refine and update segments

Donors change over time. Someone who gave once may become a long-term supporter, or a frequent donor may drop off. That’s why it’s important to update your segments regularly. Set a schedule—quarterly or twice a year—to review donor data and adjust your segmentation strategy as needed. This keeps your outreach fresh and relevant.

Measuring success: Tracking donor segmentation impact

Donor segmentation isn’t just about organizing your list—it’s about improving your fundraising results. To know if it’s working, you need to track the right data. Here’s how to measure the impact of your segmentation strategy.

Retention rates: Are donors sticking around?

One of the biggest benefits of donor segmentation is improving retention. If donors are staying engaged and giving year after year, your segmentation strategy is doing its job. Track how many donors return after their first gift and compare your retention rate over time.

Donation frequency: Are donors giving more often?

A strong segmentation strategy can turn one-time donors into long-term supporters. Look at whether your segmented donors are giving more frequently. If you notice more monthly donors or repeat gifts, your strategy is working.

Average gift size: Are donations increasing?

Segmenting major donors and tailoring your messaging to them can lead to larger contributions. If you see an increase in average gift size, it means your targeted outreach is making an impact.

Engagement rates: Are donors interacting with your messages?

If you’re segmenting by communication preferences, you should see better engagement. Track email open rates, click-through rates, event attendance, and social media interactions. If more donors are responding to your messages, it’s a sign that segmentation is helping you connect in meaningful ways.

Lapsed donor reactivation: Are past donors coming back?

One of the most powerful ways to use segmentation is re-engaging lapsed donors. Track how many past donors return after receiving a targeted email or phone call. If more of them start giving again, your segmentation strategy is helping rebuild relationships.

Campaign performance: Are segmented appeals outperforming general appeals?

Compare fundraising campaigns that use segmentation to those that don’t. If segmented campaigns bring in higher response rates, bigger gifts, or better retention, you’ll know that personalization is paying off.

Making donor segmentation work for you

Donor segmentation isn’t just a nice-to-have—it’s a game-changer for nonprofits that want to build stronger donor relationships, boost retention, and raise more funds. By grouping donors based on their behavior, giving patterns, and communication preferences, you can create more meaningful connections and make every interaction count.

The key is to start simple. You don’t need a massive database or advanced tech to segment your donors effectively. Even small changes—like personalizing thank-you messages or tailoring outreach for major donors, lapsed donors, and recurring supporters—can make a big impact.

If you’re ready to take your fundraising to the next level, Harness makes donor segmentation easy. Not only does our platform help you track donor data, automate outreach, and build stronger relationships—it also comes with the support of a team that can help you develop the right segmentation strategy to make it all work.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best way to segment my nonprofit’s donors?

The best way to segment donors is by using data that reflects their giving habits and engagement levels. Start with basic categories like giving frequency, donation amount, communication preferences, and event attendance. As you gather more insights, refine your segments to make them even more targeted.

How does donor segmentation improve fundraising efforts?

Donor segmentation helps you send personalized messages that resonate. Instead of treating all donors the same, you tailor your outreach based on what’s most relevant to them. This increases engagement, improves retention rates, and ultimately boosts donations.

How often should donor segments be updated?

At a minimum, review your donor segments quarterly. Donors’ giving habits change, and keeping your segments updated ensures you’re sending the right messages at the right time. If you notice a drop in engagement, revisit your strategy and adjust accordingly.

What tools can help with donor segmentation?

A CRM (Customer Relationship Management) system is one of the best tools for tracking and segmenting donors. Platforms like Harness automate segmentation, making it easier to create personalized campaigns without extra manual work.

How can I re-engage lapsed donors using segmentation?

First, create a segment for lapsed donors—those who haven’t given in a while. Then, send a personalized message reminding them of their past impact and inviting them to give again. A special offer, event invite, or heartfelt story can be the nudge they need to reconnect with your nonprofit.

‍